Most of the 400 level
economics classes I have taken, have not required attendance. Nearly all of
them strongly encouraged it by reviewing the homework questions prior to the
due date or limiting the slide shows posted on compass. The classes I have
taken where attendance is required have almost exclusively been intro level classes,
one hundred or two hundred level. I think the theory behind this is that intro
level classes are needed to form a foundation of knowledge, but upper level
classes are chosen and should fit your interests. In this system you are more
or less forced to learn the intro material, even if it is in area you aren’t
interested in. However, in later classes, attendance is expected to be higher
because these classes aren’t specifically required, but rather chosen from a list.
Although this is what would theoretically happen, in reality when attendance isn’t
required not as many students show up to class regardless of the level of class.
Attendance for all my four
hundred level econ classes follow the same pattern, decent participation at the
beginning of the semester, but it trends down the whole semester, with slight
peaks prior to exams and project due dates. Personally, I always try and make
it to my classes because I feel as though I can’t learn new material with out
being in class. Even though I almost always go to class, I rarely ask questions,
but like hearing other students. When attendance is required, there seems to be
more participation, even though some of those participating wouldn’t go to
class if it wasn’t required. I like when attendance is required because I was
going to go regardless, and I get the benefit of hearing other people’s
questions. Even though I am almost certainly in the minority, one change I
would make to the design of this class is having required attendance. This
would increase overall class attendance and I think it would promote more
engagement in class. I would have come to more classes had it been required,
not because it was required but because it would make the discussions in class
better. With more people discussing topics and ideas in class, I think more
people would also not be afraid to speak their ideas and share their questions.
The other unique aspect of this class, having flexible
deadlines, is something I have never experienced before. Personally, I really
enjoyed this policy because it made it easier to plan out my homework. My other
classes have a decent amount of homework due on Thursdays and Fridays, so
having flexible deadlines allowed me to work on the blogs during the weekend,
when I am usually freer. I almost always did the Excel homework on time, the
one exception being the final one I forgot about and turned in late. I never
had to use this policy for the excel homework, but for the blogging it was very
helpful. This policy allowed me to alter the deadlines slightly to fit my
schedule better. I feel as though overall this improved the quality of my work
for the class. I’m sure some students used this policy to take far longer to
submit their assignments, but overall, I feel that having flexible deadlines made
it easier to truly focus on my assignments.
While you were in the minority about actually coming to class, you were in the majority of the class on the requiring attendance part. And I thought it interesting that you wanted that for others so you could hear their questions. I did think those who came near the end were unusually quiet, but might it be that most students are that way these days? If so, would you benefit from having a room full of students who were like you in not wanting to speak up?
ReplyDeleteSo, I wonder, if I had you work in small groups, which we did a couple of times this semester but it wasn't a regular thing, would you be more comfortable there? In class later today I'm going to push this hypothetical further. If you have a chance to read this before class, maybe you can think it through.
On the soft deadlines, I have to say that being retired I can accommodate this but if I were working full time and had many other obligations I probably couldn't. So, in that sense soft deadlines were a gift to the class. I wonder if you or other students considered it from that perspective.